Workzoom vs OrangeHRM: an honest look
We break down pricing, Caribbean compliance, implementation, and support when comparing Workzoom and OrangeHRM. No vendor spin.
Which platform is right for your team?
Both platforms have their strengths. Here is where each one excels so you can find the right fit for your organization.
Choose Workzoom if…
- Need native payroll, not just HR
- Require NIB, NIS, or PAYE statutory compliance
- Want all-in-one HR, payroll, scheduling, and talent in one platform
- Prefer transparent pricing with no hidden module costs
- Need month-to-month flexibility
Choose OrangeHRM if…
- Under 50 employees and only need basic HR (no payroll)
- Want a free Starter tier with no cost commitment
- Already have a separate payroll provider and want to keep it
- Have in-house IT to manage open-source customization
- Comfortable sourcing your own training (OrangeHRM training is a common pain point)
How Workzoom and OrangeHRM stack up
| Feature | Workzoom | OrangeHRM | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll | |||
| Native payroll processing | OrangeHRM has no built-in payroll | ||
| Bahamas NIB compliance | OrangeHRM has no Caribbean statutory compliance | ||
| Jamaica NIS/PAYE compliance | Partial | HR, Workforce, Talent available. Payroll not yet live. | |
| Trinidad NIS/PAYE compliance | Partial | HR, Workforce, Talent available. Payroll not yet live. | |
| Canadian payroll | |||
| US payroll | |||
| Bahamas payroll | |||
| Jamaica payroll | Partial | HR, Workforce, Talent available. Payroll not yet live. | |
| Trinidad payroll | Partial | HR, Workforce, Talent available. Payroll not yet live. | |
| Core HR | |||
| Employee profiles | |||
| Employee self-service | OrangeHRM Advanced only | ||
| Document management | |||
| Scheduling | |||
| Shift scheduling | Partial | OrangeHRM has limited scheduling | |
| Talent | |||
| Performance management | OrangeHRM Advanced only | ||
| Pricing | |||
| Transparent pricing | OrangeHRM Advanced requires a quote | ||
| Month-to-month contract | OrangeHRM typically requires annual contracts | ||
| All-in-one pricing (no module add-ons) | OrangeHRM charges per module | ||
What you actually pay
Transparent pricing, no surprises
- Setup fees
- $0
- Contract
- Month-to-month
- Training
- Included
- Support
- Included
- Setup fees
- Contact for pricing
- Contract
- Annual contracts typical
- Training
- Contact for pricing
- Support
- Tiered plans
Common frustrations with OrangeHRM
Free version lacks payroll
OrangeHRM's free Starter tier has no payroll capability at all. Organizations must find and integrate a separate payroll provider.
Paid pricing hard to pin down
Getting a price quote from OrangeHRM requires extensive back-and-forth. Users report needing multiple emails and calls to get clear pricing information.
Outdated interface, weak mobile
OrangeHRM's interface feels dated compared to modern platforms, and its mobile experience is limited, frustrating employees who need on-the-go access.
Switching from OrangeHRM?
Data export from OrangeHRM
Export your employee records, org structure, and leave balances from OrangeHRM. We handle the import into Workzoom.
Configure Caribbean compliance
We set up your statutory deductions, tax tables, and reporting for NIB, NIS, PAYE, and other local requirements.
Go live
Your team validates the data, runs parallel payroll if needed, and goes live. Typical timeline is 30-60 days.
Real reviews from real teams.
Nothing spoke to each other. A lot of manual work and a lot of spreadsheets. There wasn't a lot of trust in how things were done because we had no real ways to track our data.
Video TestimonialI came from a company that had an HR system so I very much knew what we were missing. We had a payroll system but that was it.
Video TestimonialWe've gotten tremendous value streamlining and automating processes that were formerly manual for us such as our quarterly performance reviews.
G2Statutory compliance, automated
Bahamas
- NIB contributions automated
- C10 reporting
- Gratuity calculations
- Multi-island payroll
Jamaica
- NIS
- NHT
- Education Tax
- PAYE
- HEART/NTA
Trinidad & Tobago
- NIS
- Health Surcharge
- PAYE
- Green Fund Levy
Antigua & Barbuda
- Social Security Board
- Medical Benefits Scheme
- Education Levy
Need payroll with your HRIS?
OrangeHRM has no native payroll. Workzoom includes it, plus Caribbean compliance.
- No contracts
- Implementation included
- Month-to-month billing
